A default 404 page wastes the opportunity to recover lost visitors. Here is how to design a 404 that keeps people on your site and protects your SEO.
What happens when a visitor hits a 404 page
A 404 error appears when a visitor tries to reach a URL that no longer exists or was never created. This happens for many reasons: a URL was changed without a redirect, someone typed a URL incorrectly, a backlink points to an old page that was deleted, or a website migration was not completed properly. Whatever the cause, the visitor has reached a dead end.
A default 404 page typically shows a generic error message and nothing else. Most visitors who hit this kind of page leave immediately without exploring further. A customised 404 page gives you a chance to acknowledge the error, keep visitors engaged, and redirect them toward something useful instead of losing them entirely.
What a useful 404 page should include
A well-designed 404 page should acknowledge the error clearly without technical jargon, offer links to your most important pages such as your homepage, services, and contact page, and include a search bar if your site has one. Some businesses add a brief, human-sounding message that lightens the experience and reflects their brand personality. This small touch can turn a frustrating moment into a memorable impression.
The page should also include your main navigation header and footer so visitors can find their way to any part of the site immediately. A 404 page that looks like a completely blank or broken page with no navigation creates the impression that your website is not maintained, which damages trust.
The SEO impact of 404 errors
Individual 404 errors do not directly hurt your domain rankings, but they have indirect effects that matter. If a high-authority external website links to a page on your site that now returns a 404, all the ranking value that link could have passed to you is wasted. Creating a 301 redirect from the dead URL to the most relevant live page transfers that value and keeps the link working.
Large numbers of 404 errors can also waste crawl budget. If Googlebot is repeatedly crawling URLs on your site that return 404 responses, it is spending crawl time on pages that do not exist instead of crawling new or updated content. This is more of a concern for large sites, but even small business websites benefit from keeping their 404 errors minimal and actively managed.
How to find and fix 404 errors on your site
Google Search Console reports 404 errors under the Coverage or Pages section and shows which URLs are returning not-found responses. Review this report regularly, especially after any site migration, redesign, or content deletion. URLs that were previously indexed and are now returning 404 should be redirected to the closest relevant live page as a priority.
For external backlinks that point to deleted pages, a free tool like Ahrefs Webmaster Tools or Google Search Console can identify which third-party sites are linking to broken URLs on your domain. Reaching out to ask for a link update is the ideal fix, but creating a redirect achieves a similar outcome with less effort.
Frequently asked questions
Does a 404 page hurt my website's SEO?
A 404 page itself does not cause a ranking penalty, but losing link equity from backlinks pointing to deleted pages and wasting crawl budget on dead URLs both have indirect negative effects on SEO performance.
How do I create a custom 404 page?
On WordPress, most themes allow you to edit or replace the 404 template from the theme editor or customiser. On other platforms like Squarespace or Webflow, there is usually a dedicated section in settings for customising the 404 page.
Need help applying this to your website?
We help businesses turn strategy into high-performance websites, content systems, and technical SEO improvements that support long-term Google visibility.
Related articles
Back to blogAI Product Development
Shipping AI features users actually want
A practical playbook for going from prompt prototypes to production-grade AI products.
Design Systems
Design systems that scale beyond 10 designers
Tokens, governance and the boring rituals that keep large design systems healthy.
Web Performance
Edge rendering in 2025: what we shipped and learned
Lessons from migrating four production sites to edge-first architectures.